Concerned Citizens of Ulysses Speaks Out On Gas Drilling

The following article was written by Concerned Citizens of Ulysses, a citizen group forming in order to deal with the prospect of natural gas drilling in our town:

“Dear Friends and Neighbors:

You may have heard about the prospect of drilling for natural gas in Tompkins County. In fact, you have a very good chance of living on or near land that has already been leased to gas companies since close to half of the County has already signed up.

Many of us heat our homes with natural gas because it is generally considered to be the “cleanest” fossil fuel available and will doubtlessly be a mainstay of the American energy generation system for the next several decades as we make the slow shift to more renewable and sensible sources. Is it ethically and morally defensible to heat your house with natural gas and fight to prevent companies from drilling in your neighbor’s adjacent fields?

You bet it is. It’s okay to be a NIMBY on this issue. There are trillions of cubic feet of natural gas beneath American soil. Currently natural gas prices are at multi-year lows because supply is so plentiful. We are NOT in a natural gas crisis in this country. There is no earthly reason to drill for natural gas in Tompkins County except greed. But we are inviting a health crisis in Tompkins county and other residential and agricultural areas where natural gas companies are gobbling up land leases if we don’t attempt to regulate natural gas drilling now!

WHY IS THIS A PROBLEM?
Halliburton and other energy companies have developed a means of siphoning natural gas from the Marcellus shale which lies under much of New York State and northeastern Pennsylvania with a technique called hydraulic fracturing (hydrofracking). This involves drilling wells into the shale (six to eight thousand feet below the surface of the earth) and forcing a poisonous mixture of water and unknown chemicals under pressure into the holes to force out the gas. The wells are drilled vertically but can run horizontally for miles beneath our homes, our wells, our water supplies, our children…well you get the picture. What is so bad about fracking fluid? Nobody knows except Halliburton and other gas drillers because they claim the fluid they use is proprietary and patent protected. More than a 1000 documented incidents of water contamination have occurred in New Mexico, Ohio, Alabama and other places where fracking fluid has been inserted into the water supplies of local communities. Recent information from Texas which is riddled with hydrofracked wells suggests that the technique may precipitate earthquakes. People and animals have died as a result of exposure to hydrofracking fluid but the extent of the danger is unknown at the moment. And even when a drilling process is proceeding as it should, the activity involved in working each well involves delivery of millions of gallons of water weekly and constant and deafening drilling and pumping of fracking fluid as long as the well is active. Would you want one in your backyard or across the street? And where would natural gas companies get these untold millions of gallons of water? From OUR water supplies and Lake Cayuga itself.

AREN’T THERE FEDERAL AND LOCAL LAWS PROTECTING OUR WATER SUPPLIES?
Yes, the Safe Drinking Water Act is a Federal mandate designed to do just what its name implies, namely insure safe drinking water for Americans. But in 2005 working with a Bush administration friendly to their goals the natural gas industry succeeded in exempting hydrofracking operations from governance by the Safe Drinking Water Act. But wait! Just because the Federal government has abdicated its responsibility to protect our water supplies, what about our State and Local governments and agencies? Unfortunately after defanging the Federal mandate incredibly the gas industry was also successful in pushing through NY State Environmental Conservation Law Article 23 which in effect prevents local town and county governments from regulating gas drilling activity within their jurisdictions. And as for the DEC that presumably protects New York State citizens from activities hazardous to health and/or the environment…well, the DEC is the agency that hands out gas drilling permits to gas companies and in fact has opened up some State forests to this activity…so far.

SO WHAT CAN YOU DO?
Look into the mirror! It is up to each of us to get concerned, involved and active NOW if there is any hope at all of stemming this developing environmental tragedy. At this writing, the House Committee on Energy and Commerce is considering a bill that would repeal the exemption that gas drilling currently enjoys from the Safe Drinking Water Act. If you care about this problem, please write to the officials on this Committee and urge them to recommend the legislation for Congressional deliberation. And towards that end, please write to your New York State Congressional representations and our Senators and to the State DEC. Some sample letters and relevant addresses follow. Please help us win this battle for our families and the lifestyle we enjoy in what is currently a fairly placid rural environment. If hydrofracking is allowed in Tompkins County that will certainly change!

Thank you,

Ken Zeserson and Judy Abrams on behalf of
Concerned Citizens of Ulysses (CCU)

6 comments to Concerned Citizens of Ulysses Speaks Out On Gas Drilling

  • Michelle Bamberger

    Hi Judy and KEN,

    I have 2 questions: how can I join your group (CCU) and where are the sample letters and relevant addresses you refer to in the above letter?

    Thanks,
    Michelle

  • Stephen Younger

    Hi,

    I heard Mr. Zezerson on WHCU this morning. I had a question about the eminent domain aspect of the NY regulations. Can you direct me to the law(s) or the regulation(s) that explain how this works? In particular, are the 640 acre plots pre-established, or can the driller define them on an ad hoc basis?

    Thanks,

    SY

  • Jack Young

    “It’s okay to be a NIMBY on this issue.”

    Why? What if everyone had this attitude? You can’t just make it true by saying it.
    That’s so Republican!

    Let’s see a real explanation.

  • Jack Young

    Many things have been printed in the press recently suggesting that natural gas development would be bad for the Ithaca area. But remember how Churchill described democracy – “the worst form of government, except all the others that have been tried.” Judged by this standard, is natural gas really the worst form of energy available to us? Let’s take a look ….

    First, to avoid NIMBYism, we’ll adopt the Farmers Market rule – whatever we consume should be produced within 30 miles of Ithaca. Everything looks good if someone else suffers the consequences, of course, although it’s funny how many times things come back to haunt us from afar – oil from Iraq, acid rain, Three Mile Island etc. So for the purposes of this analysis, let’s stick to local solutions for local problems. That being said, what are our main alternatives to locally produced natural gas?

    Coal – there’s a good thought. Can you imagine how much we’d have to tear up the landscape to get enough coal to feed the enormously attractive Milliken Station power plant? And coal is a clean-burning fuel, right?

    Nuclear – wait a minute, wasn’t avoiding nuclear power how we came to have the coal fired plant at Milliken Station? Unless everyone has changed their minds about nuclear power since then, of course.

    Solar – a nice idea for limited uses, but hasn’t it already come close to bankrupting the public library? And Ithaca is such a sunny place in the winter…

    Oil – that works, as long as you don’t mind what we’re doing in the Middle East to protect our supplies. And the corrupt regimes our petrodollars are supporting.

    Conservation – isn’t this another way of saying partial abstinence? There’s a great idea, just back from solving the AIDS crisis in Africa and our own teen pregnancy epidemic. But at least the theory is sound.

    Wind Power – have you been reading the papers? Not even Enfield is willing to host wind turbines. What if one fell on a school bus? Or a bird flew into one of the blades?

    Hydroelectric – sure, that power plant will be popular sitting astride Fall Creek, just above Ithaca Falls. Or maybe at Taughannock Park. We can have new bumper stickers made up that say “Ithaca’s power supplies are Gorges”.

    Lake Source Cooling – hmmm, maybe you’ve got me there, I mean, who could object to that? We could heat with the lake too. And get our drinking water and dump our waste. Just like the Native Americans did.

    So far, it’s not looking too good, but this is a very educated place – maybe someone can suggest additional local power producing options that can compete with properly managed and regulated natural gas drilling. I’ll be looking forward to hearing about them. (And yes, I did leave burning peat moss out intentionally.) Until then, perhaps we should all shut down our furnaces and stoves and turn off the lights while we wait for someone with a better idea to come along. It will give new meaning to the slogan “10 square miles of enlightenment surrounded by reality”. The dark ages in reverse, actually.

  • Kevin Millar

    Great ad in todays Binghanton Press & Sun Bulletin. I want to contribute. Good job! Thank you so much. How can I?

  • kevin preston

    jonathan cook is an idiot.all NIMBY are idiots.what makes people think that when you turn your lights on there are no consequences? NIMBY think they should have it both ways.We are spending a tttttttrilion $$$$$ fighting for fuel wasting our children for fuel and its right here. your so scared buy a water filter you idiot. P.S. jack young you said it better than me

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>