Cayuga Lake Monster: Any Recent Reports?

Along the eastern border of the Town of Ulysses, there is a dark and deep habitat, a habitat that, some people have said, contains a rather slippery secret. The legend is said to start in the early 1800s, when people began seeing a sea serpent every year along the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake, always in late winter.

Hm. A creature that only is seen when the water is cold, and even threatening to freeze over all the way? That doesn’t sound biologically right. Could there, though, be a current, seen as a like a serpent, that’s unique to that time of year? Alas, it’s too late to go back and directly observe the conditions 150 years ago. Still, I’ll be looking out on the gray waters with a newly focused eye this coming January.

The supposed monster of Cayuga Lake is most often given the name of Old Greeny, though someone who saw it back in 1979 called it Cayuga Katie. Most reports say that was the last sighting of the creature, thirty years ago. One site, however, claims that “Second-hand accounts of these beasts have continued to filter in throughout the 21st Century”.

Is this true? I’ve never seen a single sign of any creature in Cayuga Lake. Neither has my wife, and she’s done Women Swimmin’ a couple times now. Has anyone else seen, or even been told of a sighting, since 1979?

2 comments to Cayuga Lake Monster: Any Recent Reports?

  • wilson

    I’ve been face to face with Old Greeny; not more than 100 feet away from me as I stood on the northern shore of Lake Cayuga looking south across the lake; eight or nine years ago. It raised it’s triangular-tooth-filled jaws with aquatic plants hanging from it’s half-open mouth to break surface for only about three seconds before once again submerging. I will never forget that large, unblinking eye staring to the west at nothing in particular; never acknowledging my presence.
    Don’t let anyone tell you I saw a floating log or a beaver! I know I saw an animal that is not supposed to exist! By what I observed I can tell you it was standing on the bottom when it raised it’s head for me to see; not swimming; but stationary!

  • Sean

    Wilson,

    I’m painting a mural in Ithaca very soon, and have been meeting with people on this exact subject. If you could spare a little time in person, on the phone, or just email I would greatly appreciate you being a part of this.

    Sean Chilson
    howl@chilsonart.com

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>